Study: Paid maternity leave, flexible work can hurt women's wages and promotions

New reports suggests that employers discriminate against women in countries where mothers have greater rights.

Study: Paid maternity leave, flexible work can hurt women's wages and promotions

The United States is only one of two nations in the developed world that doesn't offer paid maternity leaveas a matter of national policy.

In recent years, outcry over that fact has led to a renewed push for the U.S. to develop a modern maternity leave policy—one that reflects the fact that nearly three-quarters American mothers serve as breadwinners. (Read more at 'Moms Rising.')

That lack of financial support for new mothers has been blamed for everything from a high 'drop-out' rate of female workers, to lower breastfeeding rates, to decreased rates of vaccinations for babies of mothers who go back to work early.


But a new report titled 'When Family Friend Policies Backfire' from Claire Cain Miller of The New York Times analyzes the results of several new studies on global maternity leave and flex work programs, and suggests that the United States might want to understand how to optimize any programs that it develops, in order to prevent some discriminatory effects of new policy.

Among the article's findings:

-"In Chile, a law requires employers to provide working mothers with child care. One result? Women are paid less."
-"In Spain, a policy to give parents of young children the right to work part-time has led to a decline in full-time, stable jobs available to all women — even those who are not mothers."
'"Elsewhere in Europe, generous maternity leaves have meant that women are much less likely than men to become managers or achieve other high-powered positions at work."

Miller points out that after countries implemented mother-friendly, flexible policies, many women found their careers and incomes stalled by employers who —consciously or not —punish them for those accommodations. Part of the problem, Miller suggests, is when the employer, rather than the state, is expected to bear the cost of maternity leave and flex work, employers will discriminate against employees in hiring or promotion in order to avoid bearing additional costs.

To some women, more flexible work is worth the price of decreased pay or opportunities to promote. But for others, workplace equality for women means that the government and employers must accommodate the biological reality of pregnancy and childbirth for women. Miller's report on how other nations are faring is a worthy read in the ongoing debate.

In This Article

    Sunday Citizen

    I live in the Northeast and when I woke up this morning, my house was freezing. It had been in the mid 40's overnight and we haven't turned the heat on yet. Suddenly, my normal duvet felt too thin. The socks on my bare feet too non-existent. Winter is coming, and I'd been drinking rosés still pretending it was summer.

    I couldn't put it off any longer. It was time to do my annual tradition of winterizing my home—and I don't mean making sure my pipes and walls have enough insulation (though obviously that's important too). I mean the act of evaluating every room and wondering if it has enough hygge to it.

    If you've never heard of hygge, it's a Danish word that means a quality of coziness or contentment. And what better time to make sure you have moments of hygge all throughout your house than right now? As far as I'm concerned it's the only way to get through these dark winter months (even more so during a pandemic.)

    So I went room by room (yes, even my 4-year-old's room) and swapped in, layered or added in these 13 products to get us ready for winter:

    Keep reading Show less

    A Montessori-inspired gift guide—for newborns to 6-year-olds

    There are plenty of Montessori-friendly toys that are beautiful and engaging, but also appeal to children's developmental needs.

    With so many toys out there, it can be hard to find intentional gifts for our children that are both fun and meaningful. Using a Montessori approach to your shopping doesn't mean your choices need to be academic. There are plenty of Montessori-friendly toys that are beautiful and engaging, but also appeal to children's developmental needs.

    Montessori toys are usually made from natural materials, non-electronic and foster independent play, creativity and concentration. Montessori materials are simple and somewhat minimalist in general, and this is especially true for infants and young toddlers. The world is so stimulating for these little ones already, that simple toys made of natural materials spark the child's curiosity without being overwhelming.

    Keep reading Show less

    In a recent survey shared in the Reproductive Health journal, one out of six women in the United States reported being mistreated while in labor, where mistreatment included, "loss of autonomy; being shouted at, scolded, or threatened; and being ignored, refused, or receiving no response to requests for help."

    One out of six.

    To make these numbers even more sickening, mistreatment was more common among women of color, women with partners of color, women with lower socioeconomic status, and women under the age of 30.

    (And yet people still question the validity of stating that black mothers are at a higher risk of pregnancy and birth-related complications.)


    Rarely at a loss for words, I find myself almost unable to speak.

    I am a midwife, and I am disgusted.

    Keep reading Show less