Menu

5 toddler swim vest safety tips parents need to know

Here's what a swim safety expert wishes more parents knew about floaties, swim vests and water wings.

toddler swim vest safety

Many children don't have formal swimming lessons—instead, kids rely on a toddler swim vest, puddle jumpers or other flotation devices to swim. While they can help to keep kids afloat, it's important to remember that there are risks associated with these devices.

The reality is that drowning is the #1 cause of accidental death for children ages 1-4 years old—and 88% of drownings occur with at least one adult present. From holding kids in a vertical position to creating a false sense of security, flotation devices do not ensure that your child can swim properly.

Here are 5 reasons to be extra careful when using toddler swim aids in the pool this summer:


1. Toddler swim vests hold kids upright in a vertical position—contrary to how they swim or float

Toddler swim vests, which look like life vests with a zipper or clasps in the front, are often marketed as "learn to swim" or "swim training" vests and are not Coast Guard-approved life jackets.

FEATURED VIDEO

Swim vests hold children in an upright position in the water. But what many parents don't realize is that the vertical position is a drowning position.

By wearing a swim vest, children are taught that to swim you must remain vertical, which is both incorrect and dangerous. When a child tries to swim without the flotation device, muscle memory will force them into an upright position in the water, at a higher risk of drowning.

That's why it's so important that children learn the proper position to swim and float from an experienced professional rather than from a "swim aid device" to prevent the risk of drowning.

2. Puddle jumpers prevent kids from learning how to swim properly

Puddle jumpers, which are basically arm floaties that strap around a child's chest and clip in the back, look like a combination of arm floaties and a life jacket. They are Coast Guard-approved as a Type III personal flotation device, which means they are designed for swimming in the pool and cannot turn a child's face up in event of an emergency.

Puddle jumpers, however, result in children developing an inefficient and incorrect swimming posture. When using puddle jumpers, kids are most likely to bicycle their legs and arms in order to propel themselves through the water. By doing so, they're using lots of energy which they can't sustain when they're swimming by themselves.

Also, puddle jumpers do not teach kids to reach in front of them to start a swimming stroke. The swimming stroke is an essential part of the swimming process since it helps kids develop breathing techniques and controls the amount of energy spent. Not learning the key swimming postures puts children in danger of serious injury and even drowning.

3. Toddler swim vests can create a false sense of security

Puddle jumpers, toddler learn-to-swim vests, and even arm floaties create a false narrative for both children and adults.

For children, flotation devices create a false sense of confidence that they can swim when in actuality, they can't. If they've only been in the water with flotation devices on and they've never been taught correct swimming postures, they do not know how to swim, but they don't know it. So when the opportunity presents itself, children are more likely to go into the water without their flotation devices, thinking they can swim on their own.

For parents, flotation devices create a false sense of safety. They think their child is safe because of the device and may let their guard down and be less vigilant when it comes to watching their child. After all, they're just having fun, right? But children who rely on flotation devices don't know how to swim properly—and if the floaties are taken off, drowning can occur in as little as 20 seconds.

Parents shouldn't rely solely on arm floaties, puddle jumpers or even a swim vest to help children swim. Instead, children should learn how tohold their breath underwater, flutter kick, back float, and even tread water. That way, they can swim safely and properly.

4. Toddler swim devices are not durable

Another reason why flotation devices shouldn't be trusted is because they're not durable. They can easily fail without warning. For example, toddler floaties could be snagged on the edge of the pool or be punctured by a sharp rock, causing them to deflate.

Water wings can slide off of a child's arms, and belts on a puddle jumper can come released if not fastened tightly. Flotation devices are not 100% reliable. Most packages of floaties for kids even come with standard warnings like: "While in use never leave your child unattended."

While flotation devices are marketed as a must-have for children, they're not completely sturdy or safe. In fact, some are even made with cheap materials.

5. Flotation devices contribute to water phobia

Flotation devices also contribute to water phobia because most of them prevent water from touching a child's face. If children aren't used to water on their faces, they can develop a fear of getting their faces wet, and may react in a dangerous way when it happens.

Especially in an emergency situation, if water hits their face, a child may panic or freeze in the water. Also, they might not be able to help themselves due to the fear and panic experienced by the water.

Make sure your child is taught the correct way to swim

You might want to steer clear of those patterned floaties or that cute, brightly colored toddler swim vest. Devices like those are not a secure way for kids to swim. Instead, they pose an increased danger to young kids.

In fact, flotation devices teach kids an incorrect swimming posture and give kids a false sense of confidence. As a beginner swimmer, all kids should learn from a swim instructor. In a swim class, kids can learn swim strokes, water safety skills and how to hold their breath underwater—and they'll have fun while they do it.

By its very nature, motherhood requires some lifestyle adjustments: Instead of staying up late with friends, you get up early for snuggles with your baby. Instead of spontaneous date nights with your honey, you take afternoon family strolls with your little love. Instead of running out of the house with just your keys and phone, you only leave with a fully loaded diaper bag.

For breastfeeding or pumping mamas, there is an additional layer of consideration around when, how and how much your baby will eat. Thankfully, when it comes to effective solutions for nursing or bottle-feeding your baby, Dr. Brown's puts the considerations of mamas and their babies first with products that help with every step of the process—from comfortably adjusting to nursing your newborn to introducing a bottle to efficiently pumping.

With countless hours spent breastfeeding, pumping and bottle-feeding, the editors at Motherly know the secret to success is having dependable supplies that can help you feed your baby in a way that matches lifestyle.

Here are 9 breastfeeding and pumping products to help you no matter what the day holds.

Customflow™ Double Electric Breast Pump

Dr. Brown's electric pump

For efficient, productive pumping sessions, a double electric breast pump will help you get the job done as quickly as possible. Quiet for nighttime pumping sessions and compact for bringing along to work, this double pump puts you in control with fully adjustable settings.

$159.99

Hands-Free Pumping Bra

Dr. Brown''s hands free pumping bra

Especially in the early days, feeding your baby can feel like a pretty consuming task. A hands-free pumping bra will help you reclaim some of your precious time while pumping—and all mamas will know just how valuable more time can be!

$29.99

Manual Breast Pump with SoftShape™ Silicone Shield

Dr. Brown's manual breast pump

If you live a life that sometimes takes you away from electrical outlets (that's most of us!), then you'll absolutely want a manual breast pump in your arsenal. With two pumping modes to promote efficient milk expression and a comfort-fitted shield, a manual pump is simply the most convenient pump to take along and use. Although it may not get as much glory as an electric pump, we really appreciate how quick and easy this manual pump is to use—and how liberating it is not to stress about finding a power supply.

$29.99

Nipple Shields and Sterilization Case

Dr. Brown's nipple shields

There is a bit of a learning curve to breastfeeding—for both mamas and babies. Thankfully, even if there are some physical challenges (like inverted nipples or a baby's tongue tie) or nursing doesn't click right away, silicone nipple shields can be a huge help. With a convenient carry case that can be sterilized in the microwave, you don't have to worry about germs or bacteria either. 🙌

$9.99

Silicone One-Piece Breast Pump

Dr. Brown's silicone pump

When you are feeding your baby on one breast, the other can still experience milk letdown—which means it's a golden opportunity to save some additional milk. With a silent, hands-free silicone pump, you can easily collect milk while nursing.

$14.99

Breast to Bottle Pump & Store Feeding Set

After a lifetime of nursing from the breast, introducing a bottle can be a bit of a strange experience for babies. Dr. Brown's Options+™ and slow flow bottle nipples were designed with this in mind to make the introduction to bottles smooth and pleasant for parents and babies. As a set that seamlessly works together from pumping to storing milk to bottle feeding, you don't have to stress about having everything you need to keep your baby fed and happy either.

$24.99

Washable Breast Pads

washable breast pads

Mamas' bodies are amazingly made to help breast milk flow when it's in demand—but occasionally also at other times. Especially as your supply is establishing or your breasts are fuller as the length between feeding sessions increase, it's helpful to use washable nursing pads to prevent breast milk from leaking through your bra.

$8.99

Breast Milk Storage Bags

Dr. Brown's milk storage bags

The essential for mamas who do any pumping, breast milk storage bags allow you to easily and safely seal expressed milk in the refrigerator or freezer. Dr. Brown's™ Breast Milk Storage Bags take it even further with extra thick walls that block out scents from other food items and feature an ultra secure lock to prevent leaking.

$7.99


Watch one mama's review of the new Dr. Brown's breastfeeding line here:

This article was sponsored by Dr. Brown's. Thank you for supporting the brands that support Motherly and mamas.

Our Partners

Sorry, you can’t meet our baby yet

Thank you for understanding. ❤️

In just over three weeks, we will become parents. From then on, our hearts will live outside of our bodies. We will finally understand what everyone tells you about bringing a child into the world.

Lately, the range of emotions and hormones has left me feeling nothing short of my new favorite mom word, "hormotional." I'm sure that's normal though, and something most people start to feel as everything suddenly becomes real.

Our bags are mostly packed, diaper bag ready, and birth plan in place. Now it's essentially a waiting game. We're finishing up our online childbirth classes which I must say are quite informational and sometimes entertaining. But in between the waiting and the classes, we've had to think about how we're going to handle life after baby's birth.

FEATURED VIDEO

I don't mean thinking and planning about the lack of sleep, feeding schedule, or just the overall changes a new baby is going to bring. I'm talking about how we're going to handle excited family members and friends who've waited just as long as we have to meet our child. That sentence sounds so bizarre, right? How we're going to handle family and friends? That sentence shouldn't even have to exist.

Keep reading Show less
Life

Errands and showers are not self-care for moms

Thinking they are is what's burning moms out.

A friend and I bump into each other at Target nearly every time we go. We don't pre-plan this; we must just be on the same paper towel use cycle or something. Really, I think there was a stretch where I saw her at Target five times in a row.

We've turned it into a bit of a running joke. "Yeah," I say sarcastically, "We needed paper towels so you know, I had to come to Target… for two hours of alone time."

She'll laugh and reply, "Oh yes, we were out of… um… paper clips. So here I am, shopping without the kids. Heaven!"

Now don't get me wrong. I adore my trips to Target (and based on the fullness of my cart when I leave, I am pretty sure Target adores my trips there, too).

But my little running joke with my friend is actually a big problem. Because why is the absence of paper towels the thing that prompts me to get a break? And why on earth is buying paper towels considered a break for moms?

Keep reading Show less
Life