The honest truth about what you actually need to buy new for your baby (and what you really don’t)
Beyond car seats and mattresses, the list of absolute must-buy-new items is shorter than you think.
Table of Contents
Twenty years ago, when I became a mom, my budget for baby gear could charitably be described as “nonexistent.” We survived on hand-me-downs, strategic gift registry asks, and a lot of creative problem-solving. Looking back, I’m grateful we didn’t have the money to buy everything new—not just because it forced us to be resourceful, but because it taught me early on that most of what the baby industrial complex sells us as “essential” is anything but.
Two decades and countless parenting articles later, I can tell you with absolute certainty: you don’t need most of what social media and targeted ads want you to believe you need. And you definitely don’t need to buy most of it brand new.
If you’ve ever felt nauseous staring at a wall of thrice-worn holiday pajamas at your local kids’ consignment shop, you understand the scope of waste we’re dealing with. We’re drowning in barely-used baby gear while simultaneously being told we need to keep buying more.
The real cost of “cheap and new”
Let’s talk about what’s actually happening in the baby product marketplace right now. The Consumer Product Safety Commission recently recalled more than 15,000 baby products sold on Amazon—including brands with names like BBWOO, Greatale, KEAWIS, and Ourkiss. These aren’t companies with customer service lines or established safety records. They’re often just a fistful of consonants attached to products manufactured with minimal oversight and held to dangerously low standards.
Meanwhile, raising a child from birth to age 18 now costs between $297,674 and $322,427, depending on the source and where you live. For many families, buying everything new simply isn’t an option—it’s a financial impossibility masquerading as a parenting ideal.
And here’s the real kicker. Nearly 17 million tons of textile waste were generated in 2018 alone. As Marianna Sachse, founder of Jackalo, the first circular childrenswear brand, points out, “Most people don’t realize that in the U.S. alone, 85% of all textiles end up in landfills, and less than 1% are ever recycled. We often assume that once our children outgrow their clothes, they can be donated—but too often, poor quality means those garments are no longer usable and ultimately discarded.”
What you actually need to buy new
Dr. Laura Steelman, a pediatrician with Bluebird Kids Health, is refreshingly direct about where safety actually demands new purchases: “Car seats should never be bought used. They may have been in an accident that the previous owner considered too minor to mention and which caused no visible damage, but which may have weakened the seat’s structure.”
Dr. Steelman also recommends buying mattresses new—not just crib mattresses, but any mattress—because “they’re such a preferred breeding ground for bedbugs and scabies, which once in your home are so hard to eradicate.” Say less, thank you.
Beyond car seats and mattresses, the list of absolute must-buy-new items is shorter than you think. Cribs manufactured before 2011 don’t meet current federal safety standards, so if you’re considering a hand-me-down crib, check that manufacturing date. Bike helmets and breast pumps (unless certified for multiple users) should also be purchased new. (That said, breast pumps can also be rented if it’s something you only need short term.)
That’s essentially it. Everything else? Fair game for secondhand, with some smart precautions.
Where secondhand actually makes sense
“Infant and children’s clothing is something that I always would encourage buying secondhand,” Dr. Steelman says. “Once you wash it in your own detergent, it’s entirely clean and safe for your child, your child will outgrow it quickly, there’s such an abundance of inexpensive and good quality secondhand clothing available, and we generate over 11 million tons of clothing waste to landfills every year.”
But not all secondhand clothing is created equal. Sachse recommends two strategies: “First, familiarize yourself with brands known for quality craftsmanship and ethical production. Second, if you’re shopping in person, it’s much easier to assess quality up close. Red flags include patterns that don’t line up, fabric pulling or gaping at the seams, or loose threads when you turn a garment inside out.”
For larger items like strollers and high chairs, Dr. Steelman advises caution with anything containing foam padding that can’t be easily removed and washed, “as there may be mold or insects inside that you can’t see or get rid of.”
Your secondhand safety checklist
Before buying any used baby item, Dr. Steelman recommends looking for “no visible structural damage (including no loose buttons or beads), as well as every part of the item being accessible for you to clean (inside and out).” Always check recalls.gov and verify the item meets current safety standards.
Sachse adds that when it comes to clothing, fabric content matters for longevity: “Look for pieces made from 95% or more of a single fiber—typically a natural one—as these materials tend to wear better.”
The bottom line
“Whether you’re buying new or secondhand, the best approach is the same: fewer, better pieces,” Sachse says. “Keep it simple, avoid trend-driven styles and choose clothing designed to last.”
Twenty years into this parenting thing, I wish I could go back and tell my younger self that the guilt I felt about not buying everything new was misplaced. The real wisdom wasn’t in the shopping—it was in the passing down, the making do, and the refusal to believe that brand-new was the only way to keep my baby safe.
Your kids don’t always need new. They need safe, clean, and loved. The rest is just marketing.
Related articles
